The Power of Interesting Questions

Today I led two groups of students through an introduction to spreadsheets as part of our Baxter Foundations workshops. Our framing question was, “How much is that Starbucks habit costing you?” Many students, of course, said $0, but we widened the question to include other vices, like Monster drinks, Red Bull, going across the street to Portland Pie every day, or down the street to Five Guys for lunch. And we broadened the question to, “What if you put your money into a retirement fund instead?” To make this real for my students, my friend Tracy admitted to her Starbucks habit and offered to be our real case study.

Before we started creating anything, I asked the students to complete this quick survey to figure out what they knew and what they didn’t. Then we looked at the results as a group. Here’s what we found:

Group 1: Mostly sophomores

Group 1: Mostly sophomores


Group 2: All freshmen


Group 1: Mostly sophomores


Group 2: All freshmen


Group 1: Mostly sophomores


Group 2: all freshmen

Clearly, the sophomores were bringing more to the table than the freshmen. After all, they had been instructed in spreadsheets in their engineering class last year, but they were still a bit unsure of what they knew. They thought they probably knew more than they had indicated, but didn’t know what I meant by “cell reference,” for example. And remember, I teach in Maine where 7th graders are given their own digital device. It used to be a laptop, but last year many districts changed to iPads. I would have expected the 9th graders to have had much more experience with spreadsheets, but I’m seeing that the switch to iPads is having an impact on that. Very sad.

I began by explaining the situation: Tracy spends $x each day on her Grande Soy Chai at Starbucks. If we want to figure out how much she spending, and what she could be earning instead, what information do we need? And then I had them brainstorm for a couple of minutes.

Information needed: cost of the drink, how much spent each month, and interest rate for the investment.

We made a few assumptions:

  • Tracy could find a mutual fund, or other investment, that earns an average of 7% annually
  • that she is 25 years from retiring (I don’t actually know this)
  • that the price of coffee would not change over the life of the investments (we knew this was unreasonable)
  • that Tracy would invest the same monthly amount for the life of the investment (also unlikely)

But this is also part of problem solving. Take a few minutes to watch Randall Monroe’s TED Talk and you’ll understand what I mean.

So here’s the spreadsheet that we came up with.

So what did we learn?

  • Tracy spends a lot of money on her Grande Soy Chai. But, it’s possible that the drink adds some value to her life and is worth the price.
  • Investing early and for a long time really can pay off, even if the amount invested isn’t all that much each month.
  • Learning about spreadsheets can be fun if you have an interesting question to answer.

Do I think the students in this 90-minute workshop will remember everything that we discussed? Of course not – I’ve been doing this job way too long to think that. But here’s the beauty of it all – they have their own model to reference, be it Google or Excel, they all created one and can take another look at any time. I heard from another teacher that a couple of his advisory kids started talking about making their own coffee instead. A couple of my advisory students commented on the experience at the end of the day. One said, “It was interesting to see how the numbers involved in the Starbucks added up if invested in a retirement fund. The actual application was nice.” Another said, “The spreadsheet exercise this morning was fun. I think it was the funnest way to learn how to do a spreadsheet I have ever done. So thank you.”

You’re welcome.

Leave a comment

Filed under Baxter, problem solving, teaching, technology

Baxter Foundations

We are beginning this year with a week of what we’re calling Baxter Foundations. We realized at some point last year that we should have done more to bring our students together at the beginning of the year. They are coming from 30+ different towns and educational backgrounds. While I completely support and value the time spent building community last week, we could also use some time building that academic foundation and getting out into the community. These are also foundations of our philosophy. Full disclosure: Our Phase 3 renovation of the building isn’t going to be ready to begin classes on Monday, so we find ourselves with this opportunity.

Beginning tomorrow, our students will participate in such varied experiences as going on college visits, listening to an entrepreneur’s journey, seeing a planetarium show, walking the Portland Freedom Trail, watching a film at nearby SPACE Gallery, touring the waste-water treatment plant across the bridge, visiting the Wells Reserve to learn about the environment, and learning about agriculture by working on Wolfe’s Neck Farm. Those who stay in the building will participate in workshops as varied as learning about Flex Friday, understanding rubrics, plagiarism, research strategies, reading strategies, and teen dating violence. Other workshops include introductions to spreadsheets, probeware, and modeling. Some students will participate in some fitness and conditioning while others are working with local experts on creative writing or art. We have a workshop in food chemistry (Is that really food?) and other in project management. 

I’m excited about the opportunity to begin the year this way. It won’t be perfect, but we will take those pieces that worked, fine-tune them, and improve Baxter Foundations for next year. After all, that’s what the design process is all about. And that’s what we do at Baxter Academy.

1 Comment

Filed under Baxter

Baxter Academy: Year 2 Day 2

This Day 2 was different from last year’s Day 2 – of course. There was no furniture to build, at least not yet. We have more students now. Only 9th & 10th graders were in the building today, but there are still more of them, which is great. Today was about orientation, and reorientation. As with any project, any design challenge, reflecting and improving are important steps. We’ve done that. There are changes to what we plan to do with kids this year. Some rearranging of the schedule, a bit more time with our advisory groups, nothing huge. Our philosophy is still the same: we want our kids to be able to stand up and say what they know and believe. We want them to be fearless, and to learn from mistakes.

Today’s schedule was organized around our advisory groups. We teamed together a 9th grade group with a 10th grade group. Those groups then rotated through a series of presentations about our school: Open Campus, Flex Friday, Baxpectations & Standards Based Grading, Baxtitution, Student Government, and Student Judiciary Board, Mentoring & Advisory, and a slide show of the teachers. All of these presentations were designed by teams of 10th graders, student senators, who had minimal guidance from a faculty member. Was I nervous about what they would say? Sure, I was. Did they do an amazing job? Of course they did. That’s what impressed me the most. Not only did twelve 10th graders agree to put in extra time to create a presentation about a specific topic special about our school, they delivered that information six times and answered countless questions. And the 10th graders in the audience asked great questions, too. It was really a good morning, led by kids. Could it have been better? Sure. That’s the reflection and iteration part. Next year it will be slightly different, slightly tuned, and more effective. But I doubt we will change the overall purpose or how it is student-led. Those six topics were selected by students who spent the last day of school last June brainstorming and designing today’s orientation model.

After lunch, we got outside (another gorgeous Maine day), walked to the Old Port with our 9th grade partners (my advisory group really wanted to get to know them better), learned about next week’s “Baxter Foundations” schedule (more about that next week), and had our own design challenge for “Baxter Swag.” When you work in a school that revolves around problem solving, it’s good to get in as many design challenges as you can.

When I asked my students to sum up their first two days (10th graders do not have school tomorrow), many of them said how great it was to be back in school. Even with the changes (new students, new faculty, new building spaces, moved classrooms). One student said, “All summer, people asked me about Baxter. They know it’s a charter school and they want to know about it. The best way I could sum it up is to tell them that I am excited to come to school every day. I’m so glad to be here.” Ditto that.

Leave a comment

Filed under Baxter

Baxter: Year 2 Begins

This time last year, I began a brand new adventure, a leap of faith, as my principal said recently. I left Poland Regional High School to help start a brand new school in Portland, Maine. A Brand New School. Would it open? Would kids even come? Would we survive year one? Would there be a year two? There were certainly lots of questions, and not many answers. Except, we did open, kids did come (and keep coming), we survived, and there’s a year two. We’ve expanded our faculty to meet the needs of another 100 students. We’ve revamped our schedule and our curriculum. We’ve created a school-wide writing rubric, together, with input from the entire faculty (soon to be approved), that we agree to test out during the fall term. We are moving forward.

Last year, we weren’t sure if the school would open on time. There were issues with building and occupancy permits. We spent our first day team and community building at Fort Williams Park. And by Day Two, we were in the building, putting together our cursed Ikea furniture. But it was an adventure that drew us together as a team and a community. How could we possibly recapture that spirit this time around, when we have a year behind us? After all, we’re not “new” anymore.

Fort Williams worked so well last year, that we’re doing it again, but only with 9th and 10th graders. Two hundred thirty students are too many for Rippleffect to work with all at once, so we’re splitting up. They will have our 9th & 10th graders at Fort Williams Park this Wednesday. They will host the 11th graders on Thursday, using the facilities on Cow Island in Casco Bay. Meanwhile, the 9th & 10th graders will be back at school orienting each other about Baxter Academy, and the ways that our school is different from other public schools. On Friday, those juniors, and some sophomores, will work with the 9th graders as mentors. And there will be furniture building, of course.

I’m excited about how we’ve rearranged our curriculum. We are organizing by trimesters, and we are focusing on being really standards-based. So, we’ve created these 12 week courses, that focus in on specific standards. In math, that means focusing on Algebra or Functions or Statistics or Geometry. Those are the big, reporting standards. There are course standards that are a smaller grain size, like Building Functions or Reasoning with Equations. But this is the exciting part, for me, of continuing to build this school. Figuring out what standards-based, really standards-based, graduation looks like. Not some hybrid of standards, courses, and credits, but standards. It’s a work in progress, like everything, but I’m excited to be teaching courses like Functions for Modeling, Problem Solving with Algebra, Intro to Statistics, Designing Experiments & Studies, and Programming for Beginners. That last one came from our students.

The wrinkle to our beginning school this year is the fact that our basement renovation will not be complete in time for the week that we had planned for classes to begin. But when it’s done, it will give us some really awesome spaces: a fabrications lab, complete with drill presses and table saws and a CNC router and whatever else we can get our hands on, and real science lab with benches and space to conduct experiments, a CAD focused computer lab, and a couple more classrooms.

Rather than see this as a complete setback, it provides us with an opportunity. The opportunity to pull our students together, students who come from 35 different communities, and teach them a few skills. Skills that range from how to get around Portland (so you don’t get lost at lunchtime) to what to know about your laptop and how to organize your Google drive. We have workshops on how to conduct research (it’s more than just Google?) to understanding where food comes from (have you seen Jamie Oliver’s TED Talk?) to learning how to use science probes for collecting data to just a little bit about project management.

Sure, we didn’t plan on two weeks of Baxter Foundations, but we are Innovative and Ethical and see this delay as an opportunity rather than a setback. That’s part of the payoff of taking that leap of faith a year ago. I am constantly reminded that it was the right leap to take.

Leave a comment

Filed under Baxter

Analyzing Mistakes

My 9th graders have been learning right triangle trigonometry. We decided to include this topic in the 9th grade math curriculum because they are also taking physics. An understanding of trig will help with analyzing two dimensional motion and also with analyzing forces.

So, we did a bunch of problems and they mostly got it. But not all of them and not all the time. I used Kelly O’Shea’s Whiteboarding with Mistakes idea and had them produce solutions with common mistakes that students might make when solving these kinds of problems. Then the other groups had to identify the mistakes in a given solution. It led to some interesting discussion.

“Why would you want us to deliberately make mistakes?”

What a great question, I responded. Why do you think? Here’s a sampling of their responses:

  • To make us aware of mistakes that we can make.
  • To make us pay closer attention to our work.
  • To have fun.
  • To challenge each other.
  • To teach us how to analyze work.
  • Because without mistakes there can be no learning.

A little side note.

The 9th graders at my school also take an engineering class where they practice and practice the engineering design cycle. They identify a problem, design a solution, test it out, see where it fails, make improvements, and begin again. The teacher is very clear about learning from mistakes. Apparently, that message is being heard as evidenced by the last comment.

“Because without mistakes there can be no learning.”

I’m not sure that I agree with that exactly; I don’t think that mistakes always have to present for learning to happen). I do know that I tend to learn more from situations that give me unexpected results. But the better thing here seems to be that we are helping our students to understand that their work doesn’t have to be perfect the first time. They are kind and curious and smart – and not afraid of making mistakes.

Leave a comment

Filed under Baxter, teaching

Function Carnival

I haven’t been doing a good job posting this year. Something awesome happens in class and I think, “I have to write that up.” Then I get home, and start planning the next few lessons, and I forget all about the awesomeness. It’s been a busy year.

This morning, on CBS Sunday Morning, I learned about a truly extraordinary man, Jim O’Connor, a high school math teacher who volunteers his time at the local Children’s Hospital. What made me sad, though, was his comment, “It drives me crazy when people say that school should be fun. I mean it’s nice if it could be, but you can’t make school fun.” Watch the video. Mr O’Connor really is an amazing man. I just think that it might be time for him to retire from teaching.

I mean, if learning math can’t be fun, then why should anyone consider doing it? Kids and their parents already think that learning math is a drag, so shouldn’t we math teachers be working hard to change that thinking, not perpetuate it?

I’d like to think that my students have had fun learning this year. From dissecting chocolate chip cookies to writing graphing stories to rolling balls down ramps, they’ve collected and analyzed data and created function models. They’ve studied some statistics and some functions (linear and non-linear) and now we’re working on right triangle trigonometry. With 9th graders. I’ve worked hard to make learning fun and challenging.

Thankfully, others are also working hard to make school mathematics not only interesting and fun, but helpful for us teachers to diagnose student difficulties. Take the Function Carnival currently under development by Christopher Danielson, Dan Meyer, and Desmos. Honestly, I don’t know how they do it over there at Desmos, but these little animations will tell me more about what my students understand about functions than anything I could have come up with. And the beautiful thing is that they’re engaging for physics, too. That’s awesome for me and my students because at Baxter Academy, my 9th graders are also learning physics. Imagine my glee at learning about this interesting new tool. I will definitely have them exploring (in a few weeks) and sharing the results with my physics teacher colleagues.

In response to suggestions from the many commenters to Dan’s post, the Desmos team got busy creating more scenarios, including graphing velocity vs. time along with height vs. time. I’m looking forward to these new situations being included in the current Function Carnival site. Maybe they’ll be ready when I need them in a few weeks. It will also be fun to have my students attempt these graphs before we go off to Physics Fun Day in May.

Here are a few more challenges in development:

Try them out. Give feedback. Encourage your students to have fun while they learn.


Filed under teaching, technology

What Time Will the Sun Rise?

This week I begin Exploring the MathTwitterBlogosphere. I’m looking forward to these missions and challenges because I need someone pushing me to find the time to write in this blog. It’s good for me. Like spinach.

This week’s mission: What is one of your favorite open-ended/rich problems? How do you use it in your classroom?

One of my favorite open-ended/rich problems comes at the end of a unit on trigonometric functions. After exploring, transforming, and applying trig functions to Ferris wheels, tides, pendulums, sound waves, … I assess my students’ understanding by giving them some almanac data of  sunrise and sunset times for a specific location on Earth. Their job is to analyze the data and create a trig function to model either sunrise times, sunset times, or hours of daylight – their choice.

The data looks like this

and that makes it somewhat challenging for students to even begin. They are reminded that they should have “enough” data to know if the model they develop fits well. I point out that the times are given to them in hours and minutes, but that they probably want a single unit (hours or minutes after midnight). From there, they are on their own to solve the problem. Usually, they work with a partner.

In the classes that I’ve used this task with, we’ve modified the amplitude, period, and midline of the sine and cosine functions. We haven’t introduced phase shift, yet. So, there is also a reminder about selecting a convenient “Day 0″ for the function they choose to model with.

What I love about this task:

  • Students are talking math, asking each other about the number of data points they should use: “Should we just pick the same day every month? Are 12 data points enough?” or “Do we just go every 20th day?” or “What should we use for the first day?”
  • Students are problem solving. They have to convert the times into a single unit. They have to make decisions about which variable to model, when to start, which type of model to use. Then, they can collect the relevant information to modify their chosen function.
  • Students are using technology. Although they don’t have to, it’s really easiest to have the kids making scatterplots on calculators or computers and then graphing their model on top of that. Then they have a built in way to check their work – they don’t have to ask me (the teacher) if they are correct. It shows up in the picture that they create.
  • Students think that working with trig models is really hard, so they feel very proud when they are able to complete this task without any help from the teacher.
  • It’s really easy to grade. Either the model fits or it doesn’t. Kids turn in their data tables and work showing how they calculated the necessary values for their model. This precludes anyone from using the old SinReg command.
  • Even though I’ve used this task for about ten years, it’s a perfect fit with the Common Core math standards (trigonometric functions) and practices. And since I live in a SBG world, this is a very good thing.

My favorite kind of assessment is one where students have to apply what they’ve learned to a different situation. Even though we create lots of different trig models in class, sunrise, sunset, and daylight hours represent a new application. And a new challenge.


Filed under MTBoS Challenge, problem solving, technology